Let’s face it: free speech for California’s teachers and educators is dead. If you are a teacher or guidance counselor in California and make an internet posting that happens to offend students, teachers, and/or administrators who make up the woke mob, you may very well lose your job. The truth of what you wrote makes no difference to the free speech-haters. Indeed, the greater the truth, the greater the amount of hatred it’s likely to draw from the mob. If you doubt this, look no further than the case of Patricia Crawford, formerly a guidance counselor at Rubidoux High School (“RHS”) in southern California. This case, more so than many, illustrates the total depravity and evil of Cancel Culture.
On February 16, 2017, a host of RHS students skipped school (itself a violation of norms and, technically, truancy) to attend a protest in support of “A Day Without Immigrants.” The protest was part of a nationwide boycott against President Trump’s immigration policies. Together with other students who skipped school without necessarily attending the protest, they made up about one-quarter of the entire student body.
RHS was an overcrowded school and, not surprisingly, the absence of one-quarter of the students made it less so. A teacher emailed the staff about the high rate of absences. Patricia Crawford emailed back: “The PROFESSIONAL staff members and SERIOUS students are here today, boycott be darned.”
Later that same day, RHS teacher Geoffrey Greer posted on Facebook that he was uncertain whether the missing workers “had the intended impact or sent the desired message.” He went on to comment that attendance in the classes he taught was down by 50 percent and proved “how much better things might be without this overcrowding.” He concluded by stating that “that’s what you get when you jump on some sort of bandwagon cause as an excuse to be lazy and/or get drunk. Best school day ever.”
Ms. Crawford commented on Greer’s post as follows: “Cafeteria was much cleaner after lunch, lunch, itself, went quicker, less traffic on the roads and no discipline issues today. More, please.” Note the likely truth of these comments: if attendance was down by one-quarter, it stands to reason that lunch would go quicker and there would be less traffic on the roads. If students routinely left some trash around, the mere fact of fewer students would imply less trash (with no implication that those who skipped school were any dirtier than their counterparts who chose to follow the rules and attend school). Discipline issues could be determined based upon the school’s records, but, again, if discipline issues arose equally per capita among those who boycotted and those who did not, fewer students would imply fewer discipline issues.
The Facebook exchanges continued. Several students responded on Facebook to these two posts, expressing that “many students are taking these comments in a negative way.” One student wrote that Crawford’s remarks were “very, very disappointing.” Crawford defended herself as follows: “Disappointing is to think that some of my students still don’t get it about education. Staff members who are sympathetic to the cause were at school today. The kids who care were there . . . What I saw today was more proof, just like last year, that boycotts, especially of education, aren’t the answer. It just keeps the ones who need it the most as useful fools.” Finally, she wrote on Facebook “My post was meant to be snarky. Get over yourselves.”
It was for this exercise by Patricia Crawford of her free speech rights that the Jurupa Unified School District sought to have her fired. The stated basis for the dismissal was that she had engaged in “immoral conduct” by writing the things quoted above. She was placed on administrative leave the next day, February 17, 2017. In May 2017, the District informed her that it intended to fire her. An organization named the “Commission on Professional Competence of the Jurupa Unified School District” heard Crawford’s appeal against the District’s decision and ruled in the District’s favor.
If you are shocked to learn that the Commission and the District would regard telling the truth as “immoral conduct,” you will be even more shocked to learn that the District’s and the Commission’s rulings were upheld in the California Superior Court and the California Court of Appeal.
The new definition of “immoral conduct” for educators in California is this: anything written on Facebook or other social media that happens to offend the woke mob or the media and draws their negative comments. Effectively, the woke mob and the media have been given the power to strip California teachers and educators of their guaranteed First Amendment free speech rights.
What is most noteworthy about the Court of Appeal’s decision is that nowhere in the Court’s opinion is there any discussion about whether what Crawford wrote was true. One reads the opinion in vain for any discussion about whether it was true that the cafeteria was cleaner after lunch, whether lunch went quicker or whether there was less traffic on the roads. In this new Orwellian world, truth is no defense. And to be sure, that makes sense in a twisted sort of way. If you had publicly written in Nazi Germany that Hitler was a murdering tyrant, the Gestapo would pay you a visit and your new home, if you were not immediately shot out of hand, would have been a concentration camp. Arguments to the Gestapo that it was true that Hitler was a murderous tyrant most certainly would have been unavailing. Here in California, the truth of social media postings is no more defense for educators than truth was a defense in Nazi Germany.
So if the truth was not even the slightest bit relevant in determining whether Crawford had engaged in immoral conduct, what was relevant? What, precisely, was the immoral conduct?
The District received 51 emails complaining about Crawford’s Facebook posts, she herself received 10, and nearly 40 people complained at a District Board meeting held on February 21, 2017. There is no indication any of these emails or complaints addressed the truth or falsity of Crawford’s postings; they appear to have expressed only outrage and anger. Additionally, Crawford’s postings drew widespread negative attention in the media at the time, and this was considered to have bolstered the case for a finding of immoral conduct. Crawford’s allegedly “immoral conduct” was making postings on Facebook that (1) were in all likelihood either true or an expression of her opinion and (2) happened to offend students, teachers, and members of the media.
There was indeed immoral conduct in this case, but it was not the immoral conduct found by the august body of Solons that calls itself “the Commission on Professional Competence.” The immoral conduct was that of those who had as their objective the destruction of Patricia Crawford’s First Amendment rights.
This is the new world in which we live, a world where the totalitarian Left and their apparatchiks in government seek to ruin the lives of those who oppose their vision of an Orwellian future for the United States of America. Other parts of their sinister program are to eliminate the Electoral College, pack the Supreme Court, make the District of Columbia a state, bring in hordes of immigrants who they hope will vote for them, and allow teachers to groom young children without fear of prosecution for child abuse. To say that we fought the American Revolution to get rid of people like this would be an overstatement, because in truth and fact the British who ruled colonial America were not even close to being as evil as today’s woke mob.
What must be clearly understood is that the Cancel Culture’s minions are not merely people with a different point of view, any more than the murderous Bolsheviks or Nazis were merely people with a different point of view. To the contrary, they are evil human beings who would do much worse things to us if they could. During the French Revolution, people who spoke the truth like Patricia Crawford were guillotined, and during the Bolshevik Revolution they were shot or sent to the Gulag.
Although these events occurred about five years ago, it would be a mistake to think things have changed. Indeed, they have only gotten worse. The Biden Administration has established a new Ministry of Truth entitled the “Disinformation Governance Board.” How long will it be before goose-stepping, jack-booted thugs wearing badges and uniforms will knock on your door because of something you wrote on the internet? Across the pond, Breitbart News reports that the left-wing mayor of Liverpool, England asserts that advertisements on public transit promoting an appearance by the Reverend Franklin Graham constitute “hate speech” and should be removed. And what do these allegedly hate-filled ads say? They say “God Loves You Too.”
Are you fed up? Are you worried that America in rapidly sliding into a neo-Marxist state by the radical left in control of Washington with historically narrow majorities in the U.S. House and Senate and an Executive controlled by unnamed far leftists in place of a clinically incompetent President Biden? They are desperate to keep power and complete their radical progressive agenda that will change America and our liberty forever.
Americans just witnessed the passage of the Inflation Reduction Act of 2022 without one Republican vote in the U.S. Senate and House (just as Obamacare was passed in 2010). The IRS will be hiring 87,000 new agents, many armed, to terrorize American taxpayers.
Americans witnessed the FBI raid at the Trump Mar-A-Lago home and property of President Trump, truly a first in all of American history. We know what that is about.
It is undeniable that the Democrat Party and the administrative state (the executive branches of the DOJ, FBI, IRS, et al) are clear and present dangers to our Republic and our liberty as they increasingly veer further away from the rule of law and the Constitution. What is the solution? At this critical juncture, there is only one action we can all take.
The only viable and timely solution at this critical point is to vote – yes, vote correctly and smartly to retake the U.S. House and Senate on November 8th and to prepare the way to retake the White House in two years. Vote and help everyone you know to vote. Please click the TAKE ACTION link below – we must vote correctly and in great numbers to be sure our votes are counted to diminish the potential for the left to rig and steal the midterms and the 2024 elections as they are clearly intending to do after their success in 2020.